Why the unit of property matters more than the invoice total, and how the safe harbors help with smaller expenses.
Talk to our teamDirect answer
Under the IRS's tangible property regulations, a cost that betters, restores or adapts a unit of property generally has to be capitalized and depreciated over time, while routine, recurring maintenance can usually be deducted in the year it's incurred. Whether a given expense is a repair or an improvement depends on comparing the work to the relevant "unit of property" (such as the whole HVAC system, not just one part of it), not on the dollar amount alone.
Published by Source One Stays · Updated October 5, 2026
The IRS evaluates repairs against the entire relevant building system (the roof, HVAC, plumbing, and similar), so replacing a small fraction of a large system is more likely a deductible repair, while replacing most or all of it is more likely a capitalized improvement.
The de minimis safe harbor generally allows items or invoice line items at or under $2,500 to be expensed immediately. The small taxpayer safe harbor allows owners of buildings with an unadjusted basis under roughly $1 million to deduct annual repairs and improvements up to the lesser of $10,000 or 2% of the building's cost.
Work you'd reasonably expect to do more than once over the property's useful life, like painting or replacing standard wear parts, is generally treated as a deductible repair rather than a capitalized improvement.
Usually an improvement, since it replaces the entire system, unless a safe harbor applies.
Generally it's capitalized and depreciated, though specific situations (like a short-average-stay rental treated as nonresidential or transient use) can change the analysis.
No. A large expense that only restores a small piece of a much bigger system can still be a deductible repair. It's the scope relative to the whole system that matters, not the invoice total alone.
Sources: IRS Tangible Property Final Regulations.
Related guides: Cost segregation and bonus depreciation · Vacation home and personal-use rules
This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Every situation is different, talk with your CPA about how this applies to you.
Bring in our revenue team before you commit. We'll model the market, operating approach, and management plan so you can evaluate the opportunity with clearer assumptions.